The Hidden Curriculum of Womanhood: Writing, Learning and Unlearning in SHE

by Purva Grover

I remember that the first collective image of women together came from mythological tales, art books, and illustrated histories. In those paintings, women occupied a palace room, but not the same position. Some wore silk and pearls; others braided their hair or dipped another woman’s feet into bowls of rose petals. I did not yet understand class, caste, or labor, but I sensed the difference. I also saw something else: the women seemed engrossed in conversation. I imagined these hidden quarters as places where women spoke about households, politics, art, and the world beyond their walls, adding stories shaped by experience and exposure. The setting did not erase hierarchy, yet it may have enabled exchanges unavailable in male-dominated public institutions.

Later, I connected these gatherings to literary salons and the book clubs of their time. The European salon tradition became influential in the 17th and 18th centuries. Excluded from universities and political institutions, salonnières used their homes to convene writers and thinkers and exercise intellectual influence (Goodman 1994). In hindsight, were such gatherings the earliest expressions of what would much later be recognized as feminist consciousness? It would be historically careless to label all of them as feminist movements, though. These spaces also did not dissolve class or power, nor was every women-only gathering liberating; yet when institutions denied them entry, women created alternative spaces to encounter ideas and form opinions.

Over time, I became fascinated by places where ideas were exchanged, even without a headmaster/mistress, examinations, or assignments. What kind of school was this? It resembled my all-girls’ school, Carmel Convent School (New Delhi). Seniors guided us on how to speak and sit. Friends discussed first kisses alongside their ambitions. During lunches, bus journeys and basketball games, anecdotes circulated. We scored well, and another curriculum arose from lived experience: boys, bodies, relationships, and ambitions; judgments around weight; and career, carats and crash diets. We learned to stand up for ourselves and, eventually, on podiums.

The learning, though, had begun earlier, at bedtime. Grandmothers’ princesses sometimes waited to be rescued and sometimes were the warriors. Before we could identify gender roles, stories taught us what courage, duty, and a “happy ending” looked like. They also made room for questions, letting curiosity exist without the anxiety of earning an A.

Philip W. Jackson used the term “hidden curriculum” to describe lessons communicated through social routines and social relationships rather than the formal syllabus (Jackson 1968). Womanhood, too, has a hidden curriculum. It is transmitted through instructions, warnings, jokes, silences, expectations, andliterature and popular culture. It teaches women how to look, speak, desire, marry, work, care, age, and occupy space. Some lessons help us survive; others ask us to shrink. The curriculum is rarely coherent and at times contradicts itself. Study hard and build a career, but be prepared to give it up. Speak for yourself, but know when to remain silent. Compete with men, but do not injure their pride. Look attractive, but conceal the labour it demands. Become independent, but keep seeking permission. (She, 2021)

I saw these unofficial classrooms everywhere. Women working as cleaners gathered beneath trees, sharing lunch or even picking lice, comparing wages, discussing inflation, and demanding a safer neighborhood. They exchanged remedies for toothache and offered marital advice and employment leads. Corporate women covered similar ground beside coffee machines and in boardrooms, though in a different vocabulary. Mothers dropping off kids stay back in school parking areas to discuss balancing careers with parenting.

Knowledge travels through school runs and Zoom calls; homes, salons, and WhatsApp groups. And even at kitty parties, often dismissed as a timepass activity for the wealthy, with too much money and too little ambition. Ladies’ Nights fall into much the same category. Yet what is called networking in a boardroom is often called gossip when it happens between women in a kitchen, salon, lounge, cubicle, or parking lot. The label dismisses the knowledge carried within such talk: bodily understanding, financial guidance, professional advice, emotional support, and strategies for navigating institutions not designed around women’s lives.

Who are these women, if not educators deciding consciously or otherwise what to pass on from a curriculum handed to them? Some arrive with qualifications; others teach without presentations or titles. They teach one another about oily T-zones, mutual funds, heartbreaks, promotions, or mountain hikes. The curriculum stretches from bodies to bank accounts. Each woman becomes a treasury of mistakes, milestones, experiences, and lessons, willing to offer another a shoulder, a contact, or real estate advice.

Yet women can also become custodians of the rules that constrain them. Advice about marriage may protect one woman and pressure another. A warning about clothing may emerge from concern while teaching a girl that male behavior is her responsibility. Lessons about sacrifice may sustain families while making women’s exhaustion virtuous. This is what makes the hidden curriculum complicated. Women are the curriculum’s students, teachers, critics, and sometimes enforcers. We inherit the baton, but we are not always certain whether to carry it forward, alter it, or put it down. We also learn freely when we are fearless but simply curious. We also learn best from those near our circumstances. The curriculum does not remain static because women’s lives do not.

In 2020, when I began writing my third book, SHE: Among the Many Things I Don’t Understand, Most Are Feminine, I realized I had collected its material for decades. I didn’t work with a conventional institutional archive but with a conversational one: exchanges over drinks, calls, and WhatsApp; and stories from cousins, aunts, friends, colleagues, and strangers. Some were offered deliberately; others had settled in my memory over time. Experiences dismissed as chatter helped me examine how women are taught to inhabit their bodies, relationships, professions, and homes.

Humor allowed me to address contradictions without writing another manual telling women how to live. SHE asks about folding dinner napkins, disliking one’s boss, washing bras, and choosing a wedding outfit. The ridiculous sits beside the serious because life arrives that way: love interrupts laundry; hormones interrupt work; ambition exists beside acne. Humor exposes the absurdity of rules treated as natural while making difficult subjects easier to enter; in the pages, motherhood is discussed as a possibility rather than an inevitability.

The form mattered as much as the subjects. I called SHE an interactive workbook because I did not want readers outside the conversation. DMs appear as chapters, while quotations, ruled lines, blank pages, and perforated sheets invite readers to write, tear, contradict, and contribute. A grocery list may sit beside a project deadline. The book can become dog-eared, coffee-stained, and interrupted—rejecting the idea that women’s knowledge must arrive in a polished sequence.

There is no correct order for reading SHE. A reader may begin at the back, skip a chapter or return when life makes it relevant. Womanhood does not unfold neatly from menstruation to desire, work, marriage, motherhood and aging; not every woman wants or experiences these alike. The book’s non-linearity resists presenting one life pattern as the definitive female journey.

Paulo Freire challenged education in which authority deposits knowledge into passive recipients, proposing dialogue through which learners help produce it (Freire 2000).

SHE makes a modest creative attempt in that direction. Readers may annotate, disagree, laugh, or replace my assumptions. The final chapter contains empty ruled lines beneath the title “To Be Continued—Over to You.” No author can compile a complete syllabus of womanhood—and no syllabus should harden into another set of rules.

I joke that if readers learn or unlearn something, they should not hold me responsible. Yet that possibility is central. Learning reveals inherited expectations; unlearning asks whether they deserve to survive. Now translated into seven languages, the book allows that conversation to travel without claiming that all women share one experience.

I take SHE beyond libraries to salons, offices, universities, homes and kitchens. The book returns to the kinds of spaces from which it emerged. These spaces cannot replace formal education or structural reform but allow women to recognize experience as knowledge and add to an unfinished text. Here is a school that exists as habit and instinct. What is the purpose of education if not to make thought—and therefore change—possible? Stories can honor the past, articulate a persuasive need for change, and help imagine a rigorous yet optimistic way forward.

Am I wiser because of the stories I have heard or told? Perhaps not. Have I learned from women I know, have read and will never meet? Yes. For centuries, women have relied on shared stories. We continue to pass these stories on to those who come after us and sometimes unknowingly become educators ourselves. Perhaps then counter-education begins not with one woman explaining womanhood, but with women leaving their marks on the page and continuing the conversation.

References

Goodman, Dena. 1994. The Republic of Letters: A Cultural History of the French Enlightenment. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

Jackson, Philip W. 1968. Life in Classrooms. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.

She. 2021. Among the Many Things I Don’t Understand, Most Are Feminine. Ukiyoto Publishing.

Freire, Paulo. 2000. Pedagogy of the Oppressed. 30th anniversary ed. Translated by Myra Bergman Ramos. New York: Continuum.


Purva Grover is working as an Adjunct Faculty, Symbiosis International University, Dubai.

Leave a Reply

Trending